The Little Schemer. Book review

Exactly one year ago I was in the middle of reading “Seven languages in seven weeks” by Bruce Tate. This book introduced me to functional programming with languages like Erlang, Scala, Haskell and Lisp. Now, the Lisp part is the interesting one. I was googling some things about Lisp and somehow I landed on Paul Graham’s page. His essays on Lisp fascinated me so much that I decided to learn me some Lisp for great good. So when I reached the chapter about Clojure (Lisp dialect for JVM) I actually decided to skip it and learn more on my own. After some googling I settled on Scheme (another alternative was Common Lisp). I began with reading the official R5RS specification (only about 50 pages) but that definitely wasn’t enough. On various blogs and sites on the Internet I found people talking about this book The Little Schemer by Daniel P. Friedman and Matthias Felleisen, how great and different from other books it is and how it can change the way you think. I decided to give The Little Schemer a try.

The_Little_SchemerThe first thing I noticed after opening the book is that it is indeed unlike anything I have read so far. Instead of explaining things directly, the book presents a dialogue between the authors and a reader. There are no paragraphs, just two columns of text – left with authors’ questions, the second with reader’s responses. This dialogue is very informal and usually ends up with talking about food. Sounds strange? Well, it was at first but as I went on I found this style very fun. Of course reading is not enough – you have to actually work through the code on your own and I admit that I found that part very entertaining and rewarding, especially when I was able to figure out solutions before reading them.

The book consist of ten chapters. Eight of them are dedicated to general lisp programming. Book starts with simple concepts like basic operations on lists and moves on to more and more advanced aspects of recursion. I feel that it has learned me how to think in a recursive way, which in turn made learning Haskell much easier. Last two chapters of the book are quite difficult though. Chapter 9 gives a step by step derivation of the Y-combinator. Well, almost step by step – I had a feeling that some parts were actually left out and I had problems understanding what is going on. Luckily Peteris Krumins has written a great post in which he derives Y-combinator and fills the gaps present in The Little Schemer. Even after reading that post I still needed about 3 days to understand what’s going on in the Y-combinator, but once things clicked it was my “Aha!” moment. That’s probably the most fascinating thing I’ve learned so far in computer science. Chapter 10 pursues the goal of writing Lisp interpreter in Lisp. The beauty of Lisp lies in the fact that it is actually a relatively easy task requiring surprisingly little lines of code. Check out this article by Paul Graham to see for yourself. Solution from The Little Schemer is actually a bit more complex than the one given by Graham and again it took me some considerable effort to work my way through this chapter.

At the end of The Little Schemer there are some references to books that in the authors’ opinion are worth reading. This is not only computer science stuff – among references is The Annotated Alice: Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass by Lewis Carroll – and I found one of the listed books to be very fascinating: To Mock a Mockingbird by Raymond Smullyan. It’s an introduction to combinatory logic given in a form of riddles. I’m somewhere in the middle and will hopefully finish reading it some day.

I guess the opinions on the internet were right – The Little Schemer is a great book and it really teaches how to think in a recursive way. I suggest reading it to anyone who is interested in being a better programmer, functional or not. This will be a good investment, especially that reading the book doesn’t take much time (authors warn the reader not to read it in less than three sittings).

Finally, there’s a sequel to The Little Schemer called The Seasoned Schemer. Unfortunately I was unable to find it so if any of you has a spare copy and would be willing to send it to Poland just let me know :-)

3 Responses to “The Little Schemer. Book review”

  1. Andreas says:

    Hi, jan,

    Today I read through your blog (the interesting bits) and it was fun.
    The book you are looking for is not the “Seasoned Schemer” it’s the Reasoned schemer :)
    One major project from the authors of the book is: miniKanren . A scheme library for different styles of logic programming. Visit the website : it contains lots of useful stuff. Recently they do live! Google hangouts so you may participate or watch it later on YouTube. I came to these via Clojure which has the core.logic library which is more or less a port of miniKanren. Have fun reading the book, I’ll be looking forward to your blog entries about it. :)
    Regards Andreas

  2. Jan Stolarek says:

    Andreas, thanks for the info. I think I’d like to read books in the series in order, but if I’m unable to find Seasoned Schemer then I guess I’ll go with the Reasoned one ;)

  3. John says:

    I really enjoyed this post, thanks Jan!

Leave a Reply


Staypressed theme by Themocracy